VHS 1 and 2 were better but not by much in my opinion. If I recall didn't the lead not eat the food so she wasn't drugged or something? There is a new horror compilation out now called Holidays. I generally hate anything Kevin Smith gets his hands on these days and I guess he was the one putting this together even though the shorts were written/directed by other people but Smith did one of the shorts himself(which was by far the worst one in the whole movie). Overall the shorts were kind of okay I guess but there was one short that was just amazing. Gorgeous cinematography and really haunting. It was kind of beautiful really. That made the entire movie for me and probably hurt all the other shorts because it was so much better.