
Re: The First 2-Minutes of SPACE BATTLESHIP YAMATO!
Roger wrote:
August wrote:
Any space adventure being made now (and there aren't any) is going to be compared to GALACTICA
Name three recent space adventures in addition to this that have been compared to Galactica as much as this has.
There have been none in the wake of GALACTICA (except for STARGATE: UNIVERSE), which have a similar "war in space" plot — but, just like after STAR WARS came out, and changed cinema, everything was compared to STAR WARS. The same now holds true for the new BSG. That's my point. There were series before the new BSG, with a similar style of filming and visual effects, which were not drawn against it — such as FIREFLY and SPACE: ABOVE AND BEYOND (a personal favorite of mine for it's similarity to YAMATO). I was never a big BABYLON 5 fan, so I can't comment with authority in any kind of comparison. Of course, there's SGU, which has a similar photographic palate and visual effects to the new BSG.
Interesting note: I've seen the entirety of both BSG and the new YAMATO film, and the one big difference between the visual effects style of them, is that in BSG, during space battles, the camera would go in and out of "focus", until it sought out it's focal point — an effect emulating documentary/news camera photo (which I saw for the first time in Shusuke Kaneko's 1999 film, GAMERA 3). Conversely, there is none of this technique employed in the new YAMATO — the "camera" is consistently "in focus" throughout.